|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 1:04:53 GMT -4
I needed a place for notes (since Q seemed upset that we weren't talking enough ) and I figured you guys could use them too if you'd like. I'll just keep adding to this thread the more I see, so you can either ignore it, ask questions, or blatantly steal from it if it suits you.
|
|
|
Post by surge on Jun 23, 2012 2:19:29 GMT -4
I like this thread
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:45:19 GMT -4
Ok, so this is what I'm going to do since there are no post numbers: I'll make a post for every page detailing the posts I think are significant and what I would do about them (if applicable). I may be contradictory on a few, so if you wanna use anything I say, make sure it makes sense with whatever else you're saying. Also if you feel I've missed anything, that's entirely possible. I'm doing the first 11 pages all at once, so I may get lazy.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:46:31 GMT -4
PAGE 1
There's a lot of gak on this page. Nothing particularly useful. A pretty good story post though.
Sonix was first to be suspicious to me with a novote and a short sentence claiming that he always does that. Pointless posting is antitown.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:47:02 GMT -4
PAGE 2
TJ is pretty smart and straight to the point. His two opening posts tell me that. Careful around him.
Req opened stupid. vote for one of two people for no reason? bleh.
The way DF worded the defense for Sah makes me itchy. "Should probably just be ignored"? If I were town I'd be all over that.
Pineapple treated my stupid vote nicely.
The vote on no one was a good way to stay out of the limelight surge.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:47:27 GMT -4
PAGE 3
Smash beat me to that post from DRTJR about letting Raya slide. That was weak.
Stuck made his reaction to the DRTJR post sound suspicious, too. Awful sarcastic vote.
Ansem Omgus vote was nice. Not really worried about him.
DF's defense of DRTJR was the reason I voted DF
Stuck's post immediately after that seems like pushing. I could've taken either angle with that one. maybe if we kill DRTJR we can use this post to implicate Stuck.
Then DF immediately caved. She should probably get lynched.
There's a lot of gak about previous games on this page. Not much use to me.
DRTJR's defense on his Raya nonvote is quite believable (and I'm not just saying that because I know he's telling the truth)
Fed's answer with counterexamples is also nice. Nothing scummy/townie, but it might come in handy later.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:48:06 GMT -4
PAGE 4
Smashbro seems genuine at the top of this page. We may have to kill him, he looks good.
Abrams post on this page is exactly what I would have done in his position minus the part about agreeing with a nolynch. I've always been on opposite sides as him, now that I think of it...
I'm pretty sure DRTJR softclaimed some role right here, don't know what it was. Fed picks up on it.
JGH27 is lazy on this page. If he hasn't said anything besides this I'm gonna call him out.
Sah gets sheepy here and votes DF with the rest of us
Minby's hard to read and comes off as smart in his post. I'm gonna see how much more he's contributed. May also be another good candidate for a kill.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 4:48:21 GMT -4
PAGE 5
Sah's defense is lazy and repeats others cases while contributing nothing. We could possibly ride that wagon to get DF lynched and then blame Sah for it. Will think it over.
Enter Req's other sadly random vote. This is dumb and both of those people shouldn't stand for it.
Greenarcher comes off cowardly in a no lynch post. Easily useable.
td260 comes off a lot more genuine in a nolynch post.
Raya comes off looking a little douche-ish in an FoS post targeting mostly DRTJR but also DF
Warchamp firmly cements himself in my mind as someone to be scared of. Solid reasoning has been in every one of his posts. This is where he hops on the DF wagon.
DRTJR gives a pretty weak defense here. More of an omgus thing than anything.
Ansem votes Raya with some anger. I missed this post the first time around. It makes him look... well not townish. Just... honest. Honest is hard to make lynchable.
Stuck makes an interesting post connecting Raya, DRTJR, and DF together. This player is... interesting.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 5:22:46 GMT -4
PAGE 6
Eisen opens this page lazily. He "doesn't know what to think". That's one joke vote and one fluff so far.
Pineapple is pretty aggressive here, but doesn't say anything new. Votes Raya without giving the actual reason.
DF posts defense here that's a bit of a chore to read. It's so messy it's genuine, but I can turn that around if need be. Also gives opinions of FoS. (I happen to think FoS's are fine if you just be aggressive about it)
Greenarcher votes Snake citing that he's been up to no good... I've not seen him post before this post....
DF now tries a meta defense, saying the last game was similar. This just seems desperate.
Relmitos comes in quoting a previous game for dirt on DRTJR, shows us a theoretically ironic post from Raya, and then votes DF. This guy's all over the place.
DF posts (AGAIN) to call out Relm for the all over the place post
(Excellent questioning by hudsonboy. Just sayin)
DF makes a well worded defense unfortunately. The imagery in the AtE at the end was a nice touch. It's at this point (iirc) that I would have started to have second thoughts about DFScum. Was probably claiming something here.
Weldar thankfully jumps on Req instead of me.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 5:34:54 GMT -4
PAGE 7
Req outright says out loud that he doesn't think for himself and just sheeps the strongest wagon.
Warchamp gets all weak and says he's unsure, while keeping his vote where it is. This says to me "I'm scum and I'm posting this so I don't look bad when this wagon winds up with a dead townie"
Archer stays?
Minby does the right thing in his circumstances and unvotes. Can't fault this play at all.
JGH27 replaces minby on the Raya wagon. This looks incredibly opportunistic.
Fed comes to Raya's defense quite nicely. Votes Req, which is a smart move.
Req posts a terrible defense.
Eisen ignores the softclaim and votes DF
TJ calls me out and also ignores DF's softclaim with a vote.
Day1 over.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 5:49:00 GMT -4
PAGE 8
DF gives an Itoldyouso post in twilight. Townlooking post is townlooking.
Nolynch for some reason
Weldar died thanks to the coolest group of people in the game.
DF embraces the softclaim.
TD260 talks about possible roles (I don't care, everyone has them) and votes Req
Fed votes TJ. I like Fed. Good candidate for strong minded town player. Perfect for a charge.
TJ gives sad but believable reason for trying to kill DF
Pineapple sheeps the Req vote. Boring. Don't need to kill Pineapple yet.
Req takes the lazy route again and votes the only other person WITH votes besides himself.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 6:06:25 GMT -4
PAGE 9
Surprisingly well worded defense for Req who just plain didn't believe TJ. Nice to know, could be used later.
DRTJR makes an "I'm here" post without actually doing anything.
Omicron Austin makes a lovely post. First part WIFOM, second part telling us to stop worrying about powers because it doesn't tell us anything, third part downplaying his own skills, and lastly calling me out. This is a well thought out post(except the wifom). This person may be dangerous.
Relm makes an interesting post again detailing a three way alliance. This post is important for any argument Relm will be in any time soon. I will think of a way to use it.
Avos Me Lardo posts an equally important post. Claims that Weldar's death was a coalition doing, DF is next in line, DRTJR is Mafia, and that TJ is town. Easy pickings here if we should decide to go after him.
Fed takes exception to the Coalition kill claim (that's fun to say).
Avos pushes it again
td260 agrees with Fed and calls out avos
Avos posts some stuff about roles.
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 6:19:31 GMT -4
PAGE 10
DRTJR confirms the role inquiry from Avos. Town aligned.
Eisen gives AtE. Bad defense.
Eisen posts again, this time I don't understand what he's talking about.
Excellent recovery on possible DRTJRscum by surge.
td260 jumps right on it with a decently strong push for Avos in connection to DRTJR.
Relmitos hops on Avos' wagon citing different and good reasons.
TJ doesn't even mention me, just defends and votes the less popular target, Eisen.
Fed sticks it to him.
Avos tries to defend... sort of...
Great offense by Surge, though you may need to lay low if this leads to a lynch.
DF full on claims.
|
|
|
Post by Quaetam on Jun 23, 2012 8:39:07 GMT -4
Good analysis. Felt id let you know Snake = Stuck
|
|
|
Post by johnny on Jun 23, 2012 8:46:24 GMT -4
figured that out. I think.
|
|